A handy hack for patent-checking

I’ve always wanted to find an easy way to check whether any / all words in a first set of words are / aren’t in a second set of words.

Example use case 1: Are there any words in a set of claims that aren’t in (the words of) a given prior art document? That could give some leads for novelty.

Example use case 2: Are there any words in a set of claims that aren’t in a corresponding description? That could suggest lack of support. I’ve included some screenshots below of how this hack can be used for this example.

After a few unsuccessful attempts at hacking something together, I’ve finally found something that works.

It’s not particularly elegant, and I’m sure there are products out there that can do something similar / better, but this was really helpful for something I was working on recently, so thought I’d share.

Assuming you have Word and Excel (or similar), it’s effectively free to use.

And you can use it ‘offline’, i.e. no need to upload confidential material to a remote server for processing.

This is how you can do it…

Step 1: Add the first set of words to a Word document.

No alt text provided for this image

Step 2: Create a list of all the unique words in that first set of words (e.g. claims). You can do this using the macro mentioned on this website (screenshot below).

No alt text provided for this image

Here’s a screenshot of the resulting unique word list.

No alt text provided for this image

Step 3: Paste the Step 2 list of words into column A of a fresh Excel worksheet.

No alt text provided for this image

Step 4: Add the second set of words (e.g. prior art document text, description, etc.) to another Word document.

No alt text provided for this image

Step 5: Create a list of all unique words in that second set of words. You can do this using the macro mentioned above.

No alt text provided for this image

Step 6: Paste the Step 5 list of words into column B of the Excel worksheet.

No alt text provided for this image

Step 7: Select columns A & B of the Excel worksheet.

No alt text provided for this image

Step 8: Go to Conditional Formatting –> Highlight Cell Rules –> Duplicate Values. Then switch “duplicate” to “unique”. Then select “OK”. Credit for this tip goes to one of the comments here.

No alt text provided for this image
No alt text provided for this image

Step 9: Any words that are highlighted in red in column A aren’t in column B, and vice versa.

No alt text provided for this image

In this example, I can see which words in the claims (column A) aren’t supported in the summary. I could ignore some words like “said”, but I can see that “network”, “remote”, “server” and “usage” in the claims are all missing from the summary.

I’m sure there are much more elegant ways to do this and, of course, it’s extremely rudimentary (e.g. it won’t catch plurals, synonyms, etc). But it really helped me with what I needed to do, so thought it worth sharing.

If you’re a patent-savvy tech business looking for patent help, get in touch with Russell IP here!

The information above is for general interest and information only and does not constitute legal advice.

Share the Post:

Related Posts

An illustration representing UK IPO hearings on excluded matter

eBook on UK IPO Excluded Matter Hearings

eBook on UK IPO Excluded Matter Hearings We are delighted to announce the launch of Russell IP’s eBook compilation of all the UK Intellectual Property Office’s Hearings on Excluded Matter from 2024. The eBook accompanies the table Russell IP maintains at www.softwarepatents.co.uk and is available for download using the link below – just enter your email address to receive the eBook and sign up for the Russell IP Newsletter. The eBook is an unofficial compilation of the 2024 Excluded Matter hearings at the UK IPO. To find the definitive text on any of the hearings, please use the UK IPO’s Search Patent Decisions

Read More
How Long Does A UK Patent Last?

How Long Does A UK Patent Last?

How Long Does A UK Patent Last? As part of helping clients secure a UK patent, we’re sometimes asked: “how long will my patent last?” It’s a good question, especially considering the time and effort that goes into obtaining the patent. This article answers that question, plus some related questions, to help you understand how long a UK patent might last. Get in touch with Russell IP Important note This post on the duration of UK patent protection is intended to be a helpful guide for those wanting to understand some of the key issues affecting patent term in the UK.

Read More

Gain the Competitive Edge

Let's see how we can help protect your IP

Get in touch using the contact form or the phone number below to see how we can protect your IP.

There’s no obligation to sign up for anything.